I apologize for the hyperbolic title, but I'm truly at a loss for words . . . there are no words . . . but fuck it, I'll give it a shot: so let me begin at the beginning: last week, I ran into a spate of uncited AI writing submissions in ALL of the various high school classes I teach-- the same thing happened around the same time last year . . . kids are on good behavior at the beginning of the year, then they get lazy around winter break, then a few kids get zeroes for cheating, and then-- after seeing the consequences-- they shape up again for a few months-- then they get senioritis and fall apart again-- it's a wonderful cycle-- and while some of these uncited AI writing pieces were in my college-level writing classes, which is a serious academic integrity violation and requires all kinds of bullshit: phone-calls with parents; meetings with the students; emails and meetings with guidance counselors; academic integrity forms . . . it's a terrible and tragic timesuck (and both students and parents cry . . . which is both endearing and kind of funny) but I also got a couple of AI-written assignments in Creative Writing class . . . they were downright awful mock-epic stories-- which are supposed to be funny, but AI is NOT funny-- and with these kids I was more lenient-- Creative Writing is a relaxed elective class-- so I admonished them and told them to do the assignment again for half-credit . . . and one of the students who used AI was absent so I sent her a message explaining that I recognized her piece was AI (and so did Chat GPT Zero) and that she needed to rewrite it and this morning, I noticed a reply to my message in my Canvas Inbox and upon reading two or three sentences of this rather long apology for unethical use of AI to write her mock-epic, I noticed that her apology letter for using AI was definitely written by AI and that's when I felt my corporeal body being digitized and sucked into the metaverse-- and I let out a distorted, electronic scream . . . the very same distorted electronic scream that Neo let out when they were locating his corporeal body and he was being digitized and subsumed-- and then, just to make sure, I asked Chat GPT to write an apology note for using AI on an assignment and Chat GPT went right ahead and executed this task, without noting the hypocrisy and irony, and both the message sent by the student and the Chat GPT letter began with the same weird opening:
"I hope this email finds you well,"
and then the student-- or actually the AI, posing as the student-- expresses "deep regret" and then, and this is where I just need to show you the money-- and I should point out that I would normally never exhibit student work for entertainment purposes, that's just lowdown and mean . . . but this is NOT student work, it's written by AI and it's amazing-- and while the message was longer than this . . . because AI is incredibly bombastic and verbose if you don't give it very specific limits-- this is the heart of it and it's amazing:
Your guidance and support have been valuable, and I want to assure you that your message has resonated strongly with me I am committed to ensuring that our communication reflects the genuine connection and respect that our collaboration deserves. Please accept my heartfelt apology for any unintended oversight. I value our partnership and the trust you have placed in me. Rest assured that I am diligently working on the assignment and committed to re-submitting it no later than tonight. I am grateful for your patience, and I look forward to delivering a thoughtful and meaningful assignment.
The irony embedded in utilizing artificial intelligence to craft an apology for relying on artificial intelligence is a testament to the complexities of our technologically driven era. As I navigate the intricacies of expressing remorse through the very tool that raises questions about human authenticity, I am acutely aware of the paradox. Apologizing for employing AI to draft this letter underscores the inherent tension between the convenience and efficiency that AI affords and the desire for a genuine, human touch in communication. In this peculiar dance between man and machine, the apology becomes a reflection on the blurred boundaries between our reliance on technology and our yearning for sincere, heartfelt connections.
ReplyDeleteOr at least that's what ChatGPT came up with when I said "write a paragraph about the irony of using AI to compose a letter apologizing for using AI"
I haven't spoken to my father in eight years. It's a long story. We exchanged a few emails and texts along the way. He sent me one the other day and I immediately texted my sister to see if he is going senile or had a stroke. Apparently his new thing is using AI to write his emails and he uses some down-market AI so they come out like garbage. I assume his prompt was something like "Write an email about electric vehicles to my estranged son."
ReplyDeleteholy shit, that's amazing. i love that he uses down-market AI to keep it real. and whit, I really wanted to have AI draft an email reply to the AI apology for using AI to keep the chain going . . .
ReplyDelete