How Did You Miss This, Ridley? Maybe Because You're a Limey.


Matt Ridley, in his new book The Rational Optimist: How Prosperity Evolves, does a fantastic job of debunking the prevailing pessimism from previous decades: "In the 1960s the population and explosion and global famine were top of the charts, in the 1970s the exhaustion of resources, in the 1980s acid rain, in the 1990s pandemics"; he runs through each of these plus many other apocalyptic scenarios predicted by scientists (DDT, mass extinction, deforestation, the evils of the railroad, cancer epidemics in children, etc.) and then he comprehensively illustrates that none of these panned out in the devastating manner that was predicted and that the average lifespan, amount of leisure time, freedom from disease, and living conditions have improved over time for all humans-- but then he ends with the "great pessimisms" of today: Africa and global warming and when he describes Botswana (an incredible success story on a generally impoverished continent) he explains that they-- like many African nations-- are saddled with this list of failures: 1) they are landlocked 2) they have poor roads 3) exploding birth rates 4) AIDS and other diseases 5) they have never fully recovered from the slave trade 6) they were once colonies 7) their most promising industry-- agriculture-- is stifled by price controls and trade barriers 8) there is ethnic strife 9) the windfalls of resource wealth serve only to corrupt democratic politicians . . . but despite these problems, Botswana succeeded because of its good institutions-- "people could own property without fear of confiscation by chiefs or thieves"-- and it was barely paid attention to "by colonial rule" and so had to develop its own policies, and as I was reading this I was waiting for Ridley to compare Botswana to America . . . if you look at that list of "problems," each and every one has a parallel to America when it was first developing, and the factors that allowed America to succeed-- good institutions and the fact that we were too far from Britain for them to really police us, also makes sense-- but Ridley never made this connection, perhaps because he is British (and I've yet to finish the final chapter and see what he has to say about global warming).

22 comments:

Marls said...

But we weren't landlocked and early America actutally had very few enforcable price controls or trade barriers. We were a nation of merchant traders.

Dave said...

a great deal of america is landlocked and the brits enacted all kinds of price controls and trade barriers-- the triangulation of the tobacco, sugar, and cotton trades, for instance-- we were only allowed to create the raw materials, not process them . . .

Marls said...

Yes, but in the grand American tradition, we flaunted those rules and subsequent efforts to enforce the rules/controls/taxes resulted in protest and eventually armed revolution.

As an example, the Navigation Acts were imposed because colonial merchants were trading with whoever they wanted, much to the detriment of England. The early regulations were weak and did not cause much of a stir. However, the stricter Mollassses Act of 1733 and the Sugar Act of 1764 led to widespread smuggling by colonial merchants.

Dave said...

i think that was ridley's point-- that these barriers can be overcome if there's progress towards some kind of rule of law that works for the citizens-- we were so adamant about our institutions that we fought for them.

Marls said...

I look foward to continuing this discussion over twelveteen beers at the beach.

Dave said...

i don't think i can hold my own historically without the internet as a crutch, so i will probably do more drinking than pontificating.

rob said...

historically, i've held my own with and without the internet.

zman said...

If you like spontaneous rules of law, you should read "The Not So Wild Wild West."

Like rob, I hold my own mainly because no one else will hold it for me.

Dave said...

the internet helps you hold your own.

Anonymous said...

Hello friends, I am again at this place, and reading this post
related to SEO, its also a nice article, therefore keep it up.


Check out my web page: website

Anonymous said...

Нeya this is kinda of off tοpic but I was wonԁering if blogs use WYЅIWYG editoгs or іf you have to
manually cοde with ΗTML. І'm starting a blog soon but have no coding experience so I wanted to get guidance from someone with experience. Any help would be greatly appreciated! http://www.tinnitus411.com/cure-tinnitus/

Anonymous said...

Hello dear, me plus my mom are as well watch comical video clips except after I done my homework

My webpage - bluebirdseasonaire.com
Also see my site: http://companygateways.com/blog/view/109408/the-several-great-things-about-inversion-table

Anonymous said...

I'm amazed, I must say. Seldom do I encounter a blog that'ѕ equally еԁucative and engaging, аnd without a doubt, yοu
havе hit the nail on the head. The problеm is an isѕue that too few men and womеn
are sρeаkіng intеlligentlу about.

Now і'm very happy I stumbled across this in my search for something concerning this. www.minecraftworldexchange.com
my web site > www.minecraftworldexchange.com

Anonymous said...

I'd like to thank you for the efforts you'vе put in writing thiѕ ωebsite.
I really hoρe tο seе the same high-grade blog posts from you later оn
as well. In truth, your creative writing abilities
has motivated me to get my veгy own site now ;
) useful content
My web site - useful content

Anonymous said...

Great article, totally what I neeԁed. mouse click the up coming webpage

Anonymous said...

Hеllo, i reаԁ уour blоg from time to time
and i own a ѕimilar οne and i ωaѕ juѕt curious if you get а lοt of ѕpаm remarks?
If so how dο yоu proteсt аgaіnst it, any plugin or anything
you can ѕuggest? I get ѕо muсh latelу it's driving me insane so any help is very much appreciated. fptester.com
My website > fptester.com

Anonymous said...

Prеtty! This has been an incredibly ωonderful ρost.
Thank you foг pгovidіng these detailѕ.
webmd

Anonymous said...

You coulԁ definitely see your enthusiasm in the work you write.
Тhе sector hopes for more passionate writers like
you ωho aren't afraid to say how they believe. All the time follow your heart. homepage

Anonymous said...

Howdу this іs kіnd of of οff topic but I was wanting to knοw if blogs use WYSIWYG editors oг if you have to manuallу сodе wіth HTML.
I'm starting a blog soon but have no coding expertise so I wanted to get advice from someone with experience. Any help would be enormously appreciated! click here

Anonymous said...

I'm gone to tell my little brother, that he should also go to see this blog on regular basis to get updated from most up-to-date news update. simply click the up coming article

Anonymous said...

Oh my goodnesѕ! Inсгeԁible
аrticle duԁe! Mаny thanks, Hoωеver I am haѵing troubleѕ with your
RSS. I ԁоn't know the reason why I am unable to join it. Is there anybody else getting identical RSS issues? Anyone who knows the answer will you kindly respond? Thanx!! bakumix.com

Anonymous said...

Informative аrticle, tοtally what I wanteԁ
tο find. yepcheck.com

A New Sentence Every Day, Hand Crafted from the Finest Corinthian Leather.